Testimony, Tensions, and Tikkun
Teaching the Holocaust in Colleges and Universities
- PUBLISHED: June 2007
- SUBJECT LISTING: Jewish Studies
- BIBLIOGRAPHIC INFORMATION: 336 Pages, 6 x 9 in, 5 illus.
- ISBN: 9780295986876
- Publisher: University of Washington Press
The Holocaust was a cataclysmic upheaval in politics, culture, society, ethics, and theology. The very fact of its occurrence has been forcing scholars for more than sixty years to assess its impact on their disciplines. Educators whose work is represented in this volume ask their students to grapple with one of the grand horrors of the twentieth century and to accept the responsibility of building a more just, peaceful world (tikkun olam). They acknowledge that their task as teachers of the Holocaust is both imperative and impossible; they must “teach something that cannot be taught,” as one contributor puts it, and they recognize the formidable limits of language, thought, imagination, and comprehension that thwart and obscure the story they seek to tell. Yet they are united in their keen sense of pursuing an effort that is pivotal to our understanding of the past-and to whatever prospects we may have for a more decent and humane future.
A “Holocaust course” refers to an instructional offering that may focus entirely on the Holocaust; may serve as a touchstone in a larger program devoted to genocide studies; or may constitute a unit within a wider curriculum, including art, literature, ethics, history, religious studies, jurisprudence, philosophy, theology, film studies, Jewish studies, German studies, composition, urban studies, or architecture. It may also constitute a main thread that runs through an interdisciplinary course.
The first section of Testimony, Tensions, and Tikkun can be read as an injunction to teach and act in a manner consistent with a profound cautionary message: that there can be no tolerance for moral neutrality about the Holocaust, and that there is no subject in the humanities or social sciences where its shadow has not reached. The second section is devoted to the process and nature of students' learning. These chapters describe efforts to guide students through terrain that hides cognitive and emotional land mines. The authors examine their responsibility to foster students' personal connection with the events of the Holocaust, but in such a way that they not instill hopelessness about the future. The third and final section moves the subject of the Holocaust out of the classroom and into broader institutional settings-universities and community colleges and their surrounding communities, along with museums and memorial sites.
For the educators represented here, teaching itself is testimony. The story of the Holocaust is one that the world will fail to master at its own peril.
The editors of this volume, and many of its contributors, are members of the Pastora Goldner Holocaust Symposium. Led since its founding in 1996 by Leonard Grob and Henry F. Knight, the symposium's scholars--a group that is interfaith, international, interdisciplinary, and intergenerational--meet biennially in Oxfordshire, England.
Authors & Contributors
Myrna Goldenberg is professor emerita, Montgomery College, Maryland, founding director of the Paul Peck Humanities Institute at Montgomery, and adjunct professor at the University of Maryland and Johns Hopkins University. Rochelle L. Millen is professor of religion at Wittenberg University, Springfield, Ohio. Other contributors include Beth Hawkins Benedix, Timothy A. Bennett, David R. Blumenthal, Stephen Feinstein, Donald Felipe, Leonard Grob, Marilyn J. Harran, Henry F. Knight, Paul A. Levine, Juergen Manemann, Rachel Rapperport Munn, Tam Parker, David Patterson, Didier Pollefeyt, Amy Shapiro, Stephen D. Smith, Laurinda Stryker, and Mary Todd.
Foreword / Hubert G. Locke
Introduction / Myrna Goldenberg and Rochelle L. Millen
Part One: Course Content
1. Use of the Arts in the Classroom: An Unexpected Alternative / Stephen Feinstein
2. History, Memory, and City: Case Study-Berlin / Rachel Rapperport Munn
3. Looking for Words: Teaching the Holocaust in Writing-Intensive Courses / Beth Hawkins
4. Teaching Business Ethics and the Holocaust / Donald Felipe
5. Teaching the Holocaust: The Ethics of "Witness" History / Tam Parker
6. From the Archive to the Classroom: Reflections on Teaching the History of the Holocaust in Different Countries / Paul A. Levine
7. Teaching as Testimony: Pedagogical Peculiarities of Teaching the Holocaust / David Patterson
8. Histories: Betrayed and Unfulfilled / Timothy A. Bennett and Rochelle L. Millen
9. Cross-Disciplinary Notes: Four Questions for Teaching the Shoah / David R. Blumenthal
10. Developing Criteria for Religious and Ethical Teaching of the Holocaust / Didier Pollefeyt
Part Two: The Process and Nature of Student Learning
11. Students' Affective Responses to Studying the Holocaust: Pedagogical Issues and an Interview Process / Amy Shapiro
12. Keeping the Faith: Exploring the Holocaust with Christian Students / Mary Todd
13. Teaching Theology after Auschwitz: A Political-Theological Perspective / Juergen Manemann
Part Three: Progress and Process: Higher Education, Museums, and Memorials
14. The Tensions of Teaching: Truth and Consequences / Laurinda Stryker
15. An Unlikely Setting: Holocaust Education in Orange County / Marilyn J. Harran
16. The Importance of Teaching the Holocaust in Community College: Democratizing the Study of the Holocaust / Myrna Goldenberg
17. Teaching about the Holocaust in the Setting of Museums and Memorials / Stephen D. Smith
18. Dialogue at the Threshold: The Pastora Goldner Symposium and the Work of Tikkun Olam / Leonard Grob and Henry F. Knight
About the Editors and Contributors
In a well-organized format, the editors of the book have compiled a highly readable set of essays offering practical suggestions for educators across the disciplines..Not only do these expert teachers encourage other instructors to include outcomes related to ethics and morals on a class syllabus, but they also encourage teachers and their students to use course material as a force for change and resistance.- H-Net
By exploring the challenges, personal and professional, to those who teach and by assessing student learning outcomes, this volume provides a valuable contribution to Shoah education. .- Shofar: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Jewish Studies
One of the strengths of this book is its scope, which invites the reader into a discussion of how to integrate the Holocaust into a range of subjects in different settings. What is most significant about the volume, however, is that the essays were written not from the vantage point of the ivory tower, but from the ground of teaching.- Rachel N. Baum, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
The book is unfailingly interesting.- Michael Berenbaum, Sigi Ziering Institute, University of Judaism